• 0 Posts
  • 30 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: July 3rd, 2023

help-circle



  • Sorry. Terrible wording on my part.

    My argument is that instead of attacking Valve for being big, you should attack them for doing bad things. Your “other comment in this thread” (I assume https://lemmy.world/comment/10668748 ?) describes an aggressive practice done by Valve. Why not lead with that? The problem is not the size of these companies per se, but the way they’ve reached that size and the way they weaponize it against competitors. Focusing on attacking the size and the monopoly status of the companies is just saying “it’s not okay to be successful”.





  • I think the whole “monopoly bad” notion is a bit off. You start opposing monopolies, but then people realized that duopolies are also bad, and next thing you know we talk about triopolies and centiopolies and whatnot.

    So I think the actual number is not the thing that matters, and instead the thing we should be worrying about is cartels.

    The defining feature of a cartel is the ruthless action it takes to kill competition. The monopolies everyone are so mad about are cartels of single companies, but the bad thing about them is their cartellic behavior - not the fact they are along in the market.

    Steam is not a cartel.





  • AeonFelis@lemmy.worldtoMemes@lemmy.mlDunes vs Star Wars
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    1 month ago

    I had one in my mind for quite a while now. Time to write it down:

    A famous-but-secretive order of women pulls the strings of all known civilization. They possess special powers, that allows them to do so, but even more than their powers they rely on their reputation and their vast network of connections. There is an important in-lore reason why the order accepts only women - the powers they use are defined by their gender, and the male version has some terrible aspects to it such that letting a man connect to it will be disastrous.

    And yet - the order has a prophecy about a chosen one - a man that will use the power to unify humanity and lead it. For generations, the order’s secret agenda was to track the bloodlines that will lead to his birth, all in order to ensure he is born under their control and guidance.

    But as stories go - that doesn’t work out. In the last generation, just before the chosen one is born, a member of the order betrays that goal. The chosen one is born outside the order’s control (though not entirely outside its influence), and grows up training under a master swordsman.

    We reach the first book. Boy leaves happily with his big happy community - which, of course, gets attacked and destroyed. Accompanied by a member of the order he manages to escape the massacre , and eventually reach the desert. There they meet up with the Bedouin themed desert nomads. These nomad are very isolated and xenophobic, but of course they eventually accept our protagonist. We learn a few things about them:

    1. While they are known through the world as fearsome warriors, in their past they were pacifists.
    2. Their women can also use the same power the order uses. They just… use it for their own tribe’s businesses instead of interfering with governments.
    3. They also have a prophecy about a chosen one that would lead them. And surprise surprise - it’s the same chosen one the order was going for. What are the odds?

    Well, chosen one or not - there is a tradition to be held. So our protagonist goes through their tests, becomes their great chieftain, takes a chieftain’s daughter as his lover (which won’t stop him from marrying a more conventional princess), and goes on to use them to do his chosen one business and take over the entire civilization.






  • AeonFelis@lemmy.worldtoMemes@lemmy.mlHe can't prove it?
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    3 months ago
    • You claimed that decentralized DRM will be good.
    • I explained why it won’t happen.
    • Your counter point was that I originally claimed that the technology would catch but makes things worse and now that you explained that it would make things better I suddenly “changed” my argument to claim that the technology will not catch.
    • I did address that counter point, saying “It can be used to make things worse, and it can be used to make things better”.
    • The “some new argument” I brought up is also a response to the DRM topic you brought up.

  • AeonFelis@lemmy.worldtoMemes@lemmy.mlHe can't prove it?
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    3 months ago

    It can be used to make things worse, and it can be used to make things better. But they way it can be used to make things better:

    1. Requires a cooperation from companies.
    2. Is against the interest of said companies.

    You are trying to argue that the very same companies that nowadays do all sort of convoluted things to take control and ownership away from their customers are going to use the blockchain to give control and ownership to their customers. I say it is much more likely they’ll use it for MTX gacha.

    Also - blockchain based DRM is so easy to bypass. Just make a public wallet which only contains the key NFTs and share that wallet’s credentials around.


  • AeonFelis@lemmy.worldtoMemes@lemmy.mlHe can't prove it?
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    3 months ago

    We are talking about the topic you brought up - digital rights management. The thing that prevents you from using software (or, nowadays, even hardware) without a license is not some magical karma woven into the fabric of the universe. It’s code that the companies put in their product. No matter how much blockchain technology improves and not matter how much popular it gets - you still need these companies to actively implement NFT based DRMs. Why would they do that? Why would they relinquish control over their product? I jokingly said earlier that it’ll happen because the trend is to make everything worse, but companies that make their product worse do it to gain more control over their users and extract more money from them.